Published on:

Proposed PERM Rule Would End Schedule A for Nurses and Physical Therapists

Part 2 of our series on DOL’s proposed PERM rule.

The Department of Labor’s November 17, 2026 proposed rule on PERM labor certification (91 Fed. Reg. 73916) would end Schedule A. For more than three decades, Schedule A has let hospitals, nursing homes, and home health agencies sponsor registered nurses and physical therapists for green cards without advertising the job. This post explains what Schedule A does today, what DOL proposes, and how employers in health care and the arts should prepare.

How Schedule A works today

The current regulation at 20 C.F.R. § 656.5 lists occupations for which DOL has already determined that U.S. workers are in short supply. Group I covers physical therapists and professional nurses. Group II covers foreign nationals with exceptional ability in the sciences or arts, including the performing arts. For these jobs, the employer obtains a prevailing wage determination and posts a notice of filing, but it does not run the recruitment that other PERM cases require. It files an uncertified labor certification application directly with USCIS together with the I-140 petition. See 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(k)(4)(i), (l)(3)(i). USCIS then decides the labor certification question as part of the petition.

Schedule A saves months. A typical PERM case requires a prevailing wage determination, recruitment, a waiting period, and DOL review before the employer may file the I-140. A Schedule A case skips recruitment and DOL review. DOL estimates that employers filed an average of about 23,835 Schedule A petitions per year in fiscal years 2023 through 2025.

What DOL proposes

DOL would delete § 656.5, remove the Schedule A procedures in § 656.15, and reserve subpart B. Employers that hire nurses, physical therapists, or workers of exceptional ability would follow the same process as every other PERM employer. They would obtain a prevailing wage determination, run the full recruitment in proposed § 656.17, submit a recruitment report with the application, and wait for DOL to certify the job before filing the I-140.

DOL gives three reasons. First, DOL reads the INA to require a labor market test before “any alien” may enter to perform skilled or unskilled labor, and it now concludes that the statute gives it no authority to exempt whole occupations. Second, DOL asked the public in a December 2023 request for information (88 Fed. Reg. 88290 (Dec. 21, 2023)) how it could measure shortages to update Schedule A. DOL reports that none of the more than 2,000 comments gave it a reliable, objective method. Without such a method, DOL says it cannot show that nurses and physical therapists remain in short supply nationwide. Third, DOL views Group II as a mismatch, because Schedule A was meant to pre-certify occupations, while Group II turns on the qualifications of individual workers.

Exceptional ability cases after Schedule A

The INA applies a different labor market test to college and university teachers and to foreign nationals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts. For those jobs, DOL may count only U.S. workers who are equally or more qualified than the foreign worker. 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(5)(A)(ii). Under the proposal, an employer would mark the application as one for a worker of claimed exceptional ability, recruit under § 656.17, and DOL would judge the recruitment results under this “equally qualified” standard (proposed § 656.24(b)(2)(ii)). DOL would not decide whether the worker has exceptional ability. USCIS would make that decision on the I-140 under 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(k). If USCIS finds that the worker lacks exceptional ability, the employer would have to start over with a new PERM application under the ordinary standard. Exceptional ability in business has never been part of Group II and would stay under the ordinary standard.

Questions the proposal raises

Schedule A has existed since 1965, and Congress has amended the labor certification provision several times without disturbing it. Commenters may argue that this history shows congressional acceptance of occupation-wide determinations. DHS regulations also refer to Schedule A, so USCIS would need to amend its own rules or treat those references as obsolete. Health care employers may also submit data showing that nurse and physical therapist vacancies persist, particularly in rural areas and in facilities that serve underserved patients. DOL has asked for that kind of evidence, and the comment period runs through January 19, 2027.

The practical effect would fall hardest on health systems. A nurse or physical therapist case that now reaches USCIS soon after the prevailing wage determination would add at least 90 days of advertising, a 30-day waiting period, and DOL review, which itself takes many months under current processing times. Each case would also carry audit risk, and any qualified U.S. applicant would block certification.

What employers should do now

Employers that rely on Schedule A should identify every nurse, physical therapist, and exceptional ability worker they plan to sponsor in the next year and file those I-140 petitions while Schedule A remains available. A Schedule A I-140 filed under current rules carries a priority date that the worker keeps if USCIS approves the petition. Employers should also review whether their current recruitment for nurses and therapists, which they run for non-sponsored openings, would satisfy the proposed rule’s “same channels, same terms” standard, because that recruitment will become the benchmark for future cases.

Zneimer & Zneimer, P.C. represents hospitals and health systems in Schedule A, PERM, H-1B, and physician immigration matters. To discuss your sponsorship plans, call (773) 516-4100 or email imm@zneimerlaw.com.

Contact Information