A Two-Part Case Analysis Under Matter of Dhanasar
Part I: Decisions Issued August 3–17, 2026
This roundup reviews the 13 decisions issued from August 3 through August 17 in the August 2026 review. Each decision applies the three-part framework in Matter of Dhanasar: the proposed endeavor must have substantial merit and national importance; the petitioner must be well positioned to advance it; and, on balance, waiving the job-offer and labor-certification requirements must benefit the United States. The underlying EB-2 classification is a separate threshold requirement. INA § 203(b)(2); 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(k); Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016).
The AAO labeled each decision below “non-precedent.” That status matters. These decisions apply existing law to individual records; they bind the parties in those cases but do not establish binding agency policy for other cases. They may still help practitioners identify how the AAO evaluated particular evidence and arguments. uscis.gov
August 3: Aviation technology and a flight-planning application
The petitioner proposed expanding an aviation technology startup developing a flight-planning and navigation application for general-aviation pilots. The AAO withdrew USCIS’s favorable finding on the underlying EB-2 classification because the petitioner’s three-year Brazilian bachelor’s degree did not establish the required U.S. bachelor’s degree equivalent. The AAO nevertheless discussed the NIW’s first prong.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted the endeavor’s substantial merit but found no national importance. Projections of 28 jobs, $2 million in payroll, and $17 million in revenue lacked an explained methodology and supporting evidence. Expert letters and industry materials did not show how this particular application would produce broader effects beyond the startup and its customers.
Prongs 2 and 3. The AAO reserved both because the record failed to establish national importance and because the EB-2 threshold classification was not established. The decision illustrates two separate evidentiary burdens: a petitioner must qualify for EB-2 before receiving an NIW, and a promising business plan still needs reliable support for its projected reach and effects.
August 4: Power-electronics research without a defined endeavor
The petitioner described an intention to develop “novel experimental setups and topologies” for semiconductor characterization, with applications to renewable energy, electric vehicles, and industrial systems. The AAO found the proposed work too vague to identify what the petitioner would actually do.
Prong 1. USCIS had found substantial merit and national importance, but the AAO withdrew those findings. Without a sufficiently specific endeavor, it could not assess whether the actual work had substantial merit or national importance. General descriptions of semiconductor research and its potential applications did not fill that gap.
Prongs 2 and 3. The AAO did not reach them. It explained that it could not assess whether the petitioner was well positioned to advance an endeavor that the record had not defined, or whether waiving a job offer would benefit the United States in light of that specific work.
The practical lesson is to define the endeavor in operational terms: the work, methods, intended outputs, and anticipated users or beneficiaries. A list of industries where research might someday be useful does not supply that description.
August 5: Logistics work and failure to establish EB-2 eligibility
The petitioner proposed continuing work as a logistics analyst. The AAO dismissed the appeal because the record did not establish the underlying EB-2 classification.
The petitioner relied on foreign education and work experience. The academic record did not include the transcripts, curriculum, or evaluation evidence needed to establish the U.S. equivalency of the claimed degrees. The employment letters also did not provide sufficient information about dates, duties, or increasing responsibility to establish five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty.
Prong 1. Not reached.
Prong 2. Not reached.
Prong 3. Not reached.
This decision is a reminder that the NIW analysis does not cure an incomplete EB-2 record. Before presenting the national-interest case, the filing must establish the basic classification through the evidence required by the regulation.
August 6: Machine learning for semiconductor defect detection
The petitioner proposed developing deep-learning and machine-learning algorithms to detect wafer defects and improve semiconductor manufacturing quality and yield. USCIS accepted substantial merit, but the AAO found national importance lacking.
Prong 1. The AAO distinguished the importance of semiconductors as an industry from evidence of the petitioner’s specific prospective impact. Industry reports described the sector’s importance but did not explain how the proposed algorithms would change the field more broadly. Letters discussed prior work or generalized benefits, rather than the future wafer-detection endeavor. The claimed chain from the petitioner’s work to employer tools, improved fabrication yield, and national chip supply was too attenuated and speculative on this record. The AAO also noted tension between the petitioner’s assertion that the endeavor was independent of any employer and reliance on his current employer’s projects to establish impact.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
Read the August 6 decision, file 01.
August 6: Digital product design for connected vehicles
The petitioner’s employer described the beneficiary’s work as developing enterprise connectivity technologies, user-experience and interface systems, and digital infrastructure for commercial mobility, fleet management, and connected vehicles.
Prong 1. The AAO agreed the endeavor had substantial merit but found the record did not establish national importance. The employer’s scale, market share, and global operations did not prove that the beneficiary’s individual design work would affect the connected-vehicle field beyond the employer’s own platforms and operations. A large company’s national reach does not, by itself, establish the broader prospective impact of one employee’s work.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
The record should distinguish the beneficiary’s specific contributions from the employer’s overall products, market position, and customer base.
Read the August 6 decision, file 02.
August 11: Maternal-fetal medicine and proposed workforce expansion
The petitioner, a physician with more than 13 years of experience in obstetrics, gynecology, and maternal-fetal medicine, proposed to work as a medical scientist addressing maternal health needs. The record referred to plans to establish maternal-fetal care units in underserved counties and train 5,000 medical personnel.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. It characterized the proposed expansion and training goals as largely aspirational. Evidence that maternal health and provider shortages are important, or that the work aligns with federal priorities, did not establish the prospective impact of this petitioner’s specific endeavor.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved. The AAO treated the proposed implementation plan as more relevant to whether the petitioner was well positioned, but did not reach that issue after finding prong one unmet.
A project’s alignment with government priorities can provide context. It does not replace evidence of how the petitioner’s proposed work will produce broader effects.
Read the August 11 decision, file 01.
August 11: Artificial intelligence to model emergency-department operations
The petitioner, a public-health researcher, proposed using artificial intelligence and agent-based modeling to simulate emergency-department operations. The planned system would help hospitals study crowding, workflow, opioid distribution, and access to mental-health care.
Prong 1. The AAO found both substantial merit and national importance. The proposed tool addressed consequential health-system problems, and the record described a potential pilot and plans to share results through publications and presentations. The AAO did not require proof that the tool had already achieved broad adoption.
Prong 2. The petitioner did not establish that she was well positioned to advance the endeavor. Her public-health background and research history were positive, but the evidence did not show sufficient progress on the technical development, a committed pilot partner, firm collaborators, or secured funding. Letters identified possible support and future collaboration, but the record showed that key project elements remained at the exploratory stage.
Prong 3. Reserved because the second prong was dispositive.
This decision separates a project’s potential importance from the petitioner’s readiness to carry it out. Strong evidence on one does not establish the other.
Read the August 11 decision, file 02.
August 11: Chemical-engineering consulting company
The petitioner proposed forming a consulting company offering project-cost control, operations troubleshooting, process optimization, and management services in the chemical and industrial sectors.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The business plan projected rapid staffing growth and increasing revenue, but did not explain the calculations or document the basis for the forecasts. Industry articles addressed the importance of chemical engineering, not the impact of this proposed company. Letters and expressions of interest spoke to the petitioner’s skills and potential customers but did not establish broader effects on the field or substantial economic benefits.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because prong one was dispositive.
The case shows why projections need more than precise numbers. A plan should explain assumptions, demonstrate demand, and connect forecast activity to broader effects.
Read the August 11 decision, file 04.
August 12: Aircraft maintenance and technician training
The petitioner, an aircraft technician, proposed performing maintenance at a major U.S. airport, applying unspecified technological upgrades, and mentoring or training other technicians.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. Evidence about aviation safety, industry growth, aircraft incidents, and technician shortages did not show how the petitioner’s routine maintenance work would have broader impact. The petitioner did not identify the technologies he planned to apply, document a training program at meaningful scale, or show how the work would improve safety beyond the airport or his employer. The AAO also explained that general labor shortages are addressed through the labor-certification process.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because national importance was dispositive. The AAO also reserved the underlying exceptional-ability question.
A critical industry does not make every job in it nationally important. The petition needs to show the scale or distinctive impact of the particular undertaking.
August 13: Cloud and cybersecurity consulting for small businesses
The petitioner, an enterprise account engineer, proposed consulting with small and medium-sized businesses to migrate to cloud platforms, strengthen cybersecurity, and adopt digital tools used by larger companies.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance lacking. The petitioner relied on the general significance of cybersecurity and the need to modernize small businesses. The record did not adequately show how her individual consulting services would produce effects beyond the businesses she served, influence the field, or create substantial positive economic effects.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
For a consulting endeavor, evidence of the market’s importance and the petitioner’s experience should be paired with evidence of the services’ expected reach, adoption, or measurable broader consequences.
Read the August 13 decision, file 01.
August 13: Rhythmic-therapy centers using music and movement
The petitioner, a drummer and educator, proposed establishing centers using rhythm, movement, and body percussion to support people affected by PTSD, addiction, ADHD, cognitive decline, and other challenges. He described the model as educational and preventive rather than clinical treatment.
Prong 1. The AAO found substantial merit but not national importance. The record did not demonstrate that the proposed centers would have broader effects beyond individual participants or local communities. The petitioner relied on broad statements about public-health needs without showing how this particular model would be implemented at scale or affect the field.
Prong 2. The AAO found the petitioner was not well positioned. His performance and teaching career did not establish success in establishing therapy centers. The record did not document relevant therapeutic credentials, specialized experience, a detailed implementation plan, or meaningful interest from prospective users or institutions.
Prong 3. Reserved because the first two prongs were not met.
The petitioner’s existing expertise must relate to the proposed endeavor. A successful music career did not, by itself, establish readiness to operate a therapeutic model.
Read the August 13 decision, file 02.
August 17: AI-enabled preventive-health platform
The petitioner proposed further research, refinement, and U.S. implementation of an AI-enabled platform for early risk identification, chronic-disease prevention, and patient-centered care.
Prong 1. The AAO withdrew the denial and remanded. USCIS had demanded evidence such as adoption across multiple states, federal endorsements, nationwide contracts, and quantified national savings. The AAO explained that such evidence may help, but the law does not require those specific forms of proof. It also corrected USCIS’s treatment of prospective impact: a proposed model need not already have systemic adoption for its potential impact to be evaluated.
Prong 2. The AAO likewise found USCIS improperly presented particular evidence, including grants, patents, and long-term contracts, as mandatory. They can be relevant examples, but petitioners may use different evidence to establish positioning.
Prong 3. The AAO rejected the requirement USCIS imposed that the petitioner prove clear national harm absent a waiver or compare the petitioner’s contributions against U.S. workers. Dhanasar does not impose those tests.
The AAO expressed no view on ultimate eligibility and remanded for a new decision under the correct framework.
Read the August 17 decision, file 01.
August 17: Restaurant entrepreneur and exceptional-ability criteria
The petitioner proposed opening an Italian-Brazilian restaurant in Florida and serving as its owner, winemaker, and master chef. He sought EB-2 classification as an individual of exceptional ability.
Underlying EB-2 classification. The AAO found he met only one of the five regulatory criteria it reviewed. Training certificates did not establish an official academic record from a qualifying institution; a restaurant operating license was not a professional license; and the evidence did not establish membership in qualifying professional associations. The employer letter did establish at least ten years of full-time experience.
Prong 1. Not reached.
Prong 2. Not reached.
Prong 3. Not reached.
Because the petitioner did not meet at least three exceptional-ability criteria, the AAO dismissed the appeal without deciding the NIW merits. Meeting a numerical count of criteria would also not, by itself, establish exceptional ability; the regulation requires a final merits assessment.
Read the August 17 decision, file 02.
Part I: What the decisions show
The most common weakness in these cases was a missing evidentiary link between a nationally important field and the petitioner’s specific proposed work. The AAO repeatedly distinguished the importance of semiconductors, aviation, cybersecurity, maternal health, and chemical engineering from proof that the individual endeavor would have broader implications.
The decisions also show that the three prongs ask different questions. The emergency-department modeling case met prong one but failed prong two because the project lacked demonstrated progress, committed collaborators, and funding. The August 17 healthcare-platform decision, by contrast, resulted in a remand because USCIS treated particular kinds of evidence as mandatory when Dhanasar does not prescribe a fixed checklist.
Part II: Decisions Issued August 18–31, 2026
Part II reviews the remaining 15 decisions. Several address entrepreneurial plans and economic projections; others concern research, healthcare, and the scope of an employee’s work within a large company. One August 31 decision turns on a procedural signature defect and does not decide the NIW merits.
August 18: Housing construction and refurbishment for Native communities
The petitioner proposed working with Native American communities to manufacture and refurbish homes, address housing shortages, and develop longer-term funding and implementation models.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. A project plan described phased needs assessments, construction, training, scaling, and evaluation. But the plan and articles documented the seriousness of the housing problem, not the prospective impact of this petitioner’s undertaking. Claims of thousands of jobs, economic benefits, and reduced healthcare spending lacked supporting detail about locations, job types, numbers, and methods.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive. The petitioner’s past work in housing was relevant to positioning, not proof of the proposed endeavor’s national importance.
A compelling social need does not alone establish that a particular proposed solution will have the claimed reach or effect.
August 19: AI and machine learning for digital-advertising fraud detection
The beneficiary proposed developing open-source AI and machine-learning frameworks to detect advertising fraud across connected TV, mobile, and web platforms, with technical documentation, information-sharing protocols, and regulatory tools.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The beneficiary’s work for a large employer, government initiatives concerning AI and fraud, and the employer’s national footprint did not establish that his specific work would affect the broader field. The record did not show that the employer’s projects would be shared or adopted outside the company, or that the planned open-source platform had the reach or use claimed.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
The case underscores the need to separate employer-specific work from an independent public-benefit track. If a petition claims that work will become open-source infrastructure, it should document development, access, adoption, or concrete plans that support that claim.
August 20: Workforce training and consulting
The petitioner proposed forming a California consulting company to train industrial, automotive, and metal-mechanic workers and improve productivity and competitiveness.
Prong 1. The AAO found national importance unproven. The proposed location was unspecified, the business plan did not identify employees beyond the petitioner, and it lacked operating details and supported projections. General publications about workforce training and letters describing the petitioner’s qualifications did not establish how this particular business would differ from existing consulting services or affect the field broadly.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
A business plan should identify where the endeavor will operate, who will perform the work, what services the business will provide, and how it will produce the asserted effects. General claims of national reach need evidentiary support.
Read the August 20 decision, file 01.
August 20: Islamic-finance and ethical-finance toolkit
The petitioner proposed designing and deploying a U.S.-regulated, interest-free and risk-sharing financial toolkit for fintech companies, nonprofit lenders, and community-facing institutions. The plan included standardized product structures, model contracts, governance materials, and AI-supported compliance processes.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The petitioner’s projected multistate expansion, job creation, and economic effects lacked explanations and corroboration. Alignment with federal financial-inclusion initiatives did not establish that the project itself would have substantial national impact. Expressions of interest and potential employment related to the petitioner’s services, not widespread adoption of the toolkit.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because prong one was dispositive.
The decision recognizes that financial inclusion may be important while requiring evidence that the specific proposed product or model will extend beyond the petitioner’s business and future clients.
Read the August 20 decision, file 02.
August 21: Cancer research and the petitioner’s research record
The petitioner proposed researching cancer treatment strategies, including therapeutic targets, immunotherapy, and radio-oncology, with the goal of improving patient outcomes.
Prong 1. USCIS found the endeavor had substantial merit and national importance, and the AAO’s decision focused on the second prong rather than disturbing that finding.
Prong 2. The AAO found the petitioner was not well positioned. The record did not document the claimed graduate program in cancer and cell biology. The petitioner relied heavily on citation counts, but the most-cited works were reviews or meta-analyses with many coauthors, and the evidence did not clarify her specific contributions. Her future plan depended on anticipated employment and research opportunities, but the record lacked documentation of those opportunities, progress, or funding.
Prong 3. Reserved because prong two was dispositive.
The decision does not make funding or a particular citation level a universal requirement. It evaluates whether the record as a whole showed the petitioner’s own success, progress, and ability to advance the proposed work.
August 22: AI systems for power-grid resilience and storm restoration
The petitioner, an energy-company manager with civil and structural engineering education, proposed developing AI-supported systems to improve grid reliability, storm restoration, and asset deployment.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The petitioner relied on the importance of the power grid, severe-weather risks, and national infrastructure priorities. The record did not sufficiently show how her specific work would affect grid resilience beyond her employer’s operations or otherwise produce broader impacts.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
The AAO also addressed the petitioner’s claim that USCIS confused her endeavor with her current employment. The decision considered her description of future work, but found that the evidence did not establish the claimed broader impact. A petition should explain how current employment provides a platform for advancing the proposed endeavor while distinguishing the endeavor from ordinary duties for one employer.
August 24: AI-enabled subsurface modeling for energy and mineral resources
The petitioner, an earth-science researcher, proposed developing an AI-enabled framework for subsurface prediction, with applications to hydrocarbons, geothermal energy, critical minerals, and natural hydrogen.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The record described important national priorities and the value of geoscience, but did not specify the planned research and models in enough detail to show how they would have broader effects. Consulting agreements, client reports, and past research supported the petitioner’s experience, but the AAO found that the primary benefits appeared to flow to employers and clients.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because prong one was dispositive.
Where an endeavor spans several federally prioritized sectors, the petition should explain the common technical work and show how that work will produce broader consequences, rather than relying on the importance of each sector.
Read the August 24 decision, file 01.
August 24: Healthcare cleaning and medical-waste management business
The petitioner proposed establishing a Florida business that would provide cleaning, conservation, and waste-disposal services to hospitals, laboratories, surgery centers, and clinics.
Underlying EB-2 classification. The AAO withdrew USCIS’s favorable advanced-degree finding. Although the petitioner’s foreign law degree was equivalent to a U.S. bachelor’s degree, the record lacked employer letters establishing five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty, as required by the regulation.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The petitioner did not support claims of healthcare-system, public-health, or economic effects with evidence tying them to the proposed business. Business-plan projections of employees, payroll, indirect jobs, and revenue lacked adequate explanation; the projections also differed significantly depending on the multiplier used.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because prong one was dispositive.
Read the August 24 decision, file 02.
August 24: Educational-access platform for African students
The petitioner, a graduate student and teaching assistant, proposed a social-impact enterprise to help high-potential African students navigate U.S. admissions and visa processes through an online platform and institutional partnerships.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The platform appeared to offer individualized advising to prospective students. The petitioner’s claims of strengthening U.S. soft power, educational diplomacy, and institutional diversity were not supported by evidence showing how this specific platform would create broader effects. Projections involving 2,200 students, hundreds of millions of dollars in economic activity, and hundreds of jobs lacked a documented basis.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
The AAO did not hold that educational access cannot have national importance. It found that the petitioner had not substantiated the projected reach and impacts of this particular platform.
Read the August 24 decision, file 03.
August 26: Earthquake monitoring and induced-seismicity research
The petitioner, a geoscientist pursuing doctoral study, proposed research using AI and seismological methods to improve earthquake monitoring, seismic-hazard assessment, and risk management, including induced seismicity.
Prong 1. The AAO adopted and affirmed USCIS’s finding that national importance was not established. The petitioner cited the importance of earthquake preparedness and federal hazard-reduction efforts, but the evidence did not connect his specific research to broader prospective effects at the claimed level.
Prongs 2 and 3. Not reached after the first prong proved dispositive.
The decision also rejected the claim that USCIS had misunderstood the proposed work merely by referring to the job titles the petitioner provided on the forms. The petition should keep the endeavor description consistent across forms, personal statements, and supporting evidence.
Read the August 26 decision, file 01.
August 26: Soil microbes, climate modeling, and greenhouse-gas emissions
The petitioner, an ecology researcher, proposed developing Earth-system and ecosystem models that incorporate soil microbial processes to improve greenhouse-gas projections and inform climate-mitigation strategies.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. Reports about climate change established the importance of the field, not the prospective effect of the petitioner’s proposed projects. Expert letters focused on earlier work and its value to other researchers, rather than explaining the expected impact of the future endeavor. Assertions about policy, food security, and economic benefits were not adequately supported.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because national importance was dispositive.
The decision noted an error in USCIS’s reasoning: its concern about whether the petitioner’s past work had been adopted as a standard or innovation belonged more naturally in the second-prong analysis. The AAO nevertheless affirmed the denial on the separate, properly analyzed national-importance ground.
Read the August 26 decision, file 02.
August 28: Nurse-led clinical-safety auditing
The petitioner, a nurse, proposed implementing a nurse-led clinical-safety auditing model in U.S. hospitals. The model would train nurses, standardize indicators, detect risks, and improve compliance and patient safety.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The professional plan and support letters described potential benefits, but the record did not establish that the petitioner’s work would influence nursing practice or healthcare networks beyond the hospital where she would work. The expert letter cited public-health sources but did not explain how this petitioner’s specific model would produce the claimed broader effects. The record also lacked supported projections of job creation or substantial economic benefits.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive. The AAO also reserved the underlying EB-2 classification question.
The decision focuses on evidence of prospective impact, not just the importance of patient safety or the petitioner’s professional experience.
Read the August 28 decision, file 01.
August 28: AI and synthetic biology for plant-based chemical production
The petitioner proposed combining AI, synthetic biology, and adaptive laboratory evolution to engineer bacteria that could produce industrial chemicals from plant-based feedstocks. Her planned projects involved engineering bacterial strains and developing software to identify promising proteins and biological pathways.
Prong 1. The AAO found substantial merit and national importance. Unlike several other research decisions in this roundup, the record included evidence of the petitioner’s prior research impact and explained why the proposed work could benefit the field beyond her employer or its clients.
Prong 2. The AAO found the petitioner was not well positioned. A Ph.D. and publications were positive factors, but citation statistics did not explain the qualitative impact of her work; the cited papers were review articles, and the record did not establish her contributions or show that others relied on the work in a way demonstrating field-level influence. The record also did not establish her role in securing funding or confirm the claimed university employment.
Prong 3. Not reached after the second-prong finding.
The decision shows that evidence sufficient to establish an endeavor’s importance may still fall short of showing that the petitioner is positioned to advance it.
Read the August 28 decision, file 02.
August 31: Healthcare analytics and medication adherence
The petitioner, a senior data scientist, proposed developing and disseminating predictive AI and causal-inference systems to address medication non-adherence and improve healthcare analytics.
Prong 1. The AAO accepted substantial merit but found national importance unproven. The petitioner pointed to work performed for a large employer whose platform served customers nationwide, including models associated with increased prescriptions and cost savings. The AAO found that the claimed benefits primarily flowed to the employer and its customers. The record did not sufficiently explain how planned publications, synthetic-data benchmarks, or an open-source software package would affect healthcare data science more broadly.
Prongs 2 and 3. Reserved because the first prong was dispositive.
The AAO also questioned the attribution of team projects to the petitioner individually. Evidence of an employer’s reach or a team’s output must show what the petitioner personally contributed and how the endeavor’s future impact will extend beyond the employer.
Read the August 31 decision, file 01.
August 31: Appeal dismissed for a signature defect, not NIW merits
This decision did not adjudicate the proposed endeavor or any Dhanasar prong. The AAO dismissed the appeal because the signature image on Form I-290B appeared to have been electronically copied from the accompanying Form G-28 rather than personally placed on the appeal form by the petitioner.
The AAO explained that a reproduced copy of a document originally signed by hand may be acceptable, but transferring a signature image onto a separate form does not establish that the petitioner personally reviewed and certified the appeal. Because the record did not establish a valid signature, the appeal was not properly filed, and the AAO did not reach the merits of USCIS’s NIW denial.
Prong 1. Not reached.
Prong 2. Not reached.
Prong 3. Not reached.
The practical point is procedural: the petitioner must personally sign the appeal form in a manner consistent with USCIS’s signature rules.
Read the August 31 decision, file 02.
August 2026: What the decisions show
Across these 29 decisions, the most persistent issue was the distinction between a significant field and a nationally important endeavor. Evidence about climate change, maternal health, semiconductors, financial inclusion, aviation safety, or healthcare access provided context. The AAO generally looked for evidence tying the petitioner’s specific future work to broader effects.
The decisions also repeatedly distinguished the three Dhanasar prongs. A nationally important project did not establish that its petitioner was ready to advance it, as the emergency-department modeling and biomanufacturing decisions show. Conversely, an impressive résumé, publication list, or employer platform did not independently establish that the proposed endeavor would have broader impact.
Economic forecasts, expert letters, and policy alignment were most persuasive when they explained the connection between the proposed work and the claimed outcome. Unsupported projections, generic endorsements, or statements that an endeavor supports a national priority did not fill that evidentiary gap.
What We Take from These Decisions
A strong NIW petition should make the endeavor concrete, explain its prospective impact, and connect that impact to credible evidence. It should separately show why the petitioner is positioned to advance the work and why waiving the job offer and labor-certification requirements benefits the United States. If the case depends on projected jobs, adoption, cost savings, or field-wide influence, the petition should explain the assumptions and support the projections.
Zneimer & Zneimer P.C. is an experienced immigration law firm that handles employment-based immigration matters, including complex petitions requiring detailed legal and evidentiary analysis. Each NIW case turns on its own record; these non-precedent decisions offer practical examples, not binding rules for future adjudications.
Chicago Immigration Lawyer Blog

