Published on:

A Two-Part Case Analysis Under Matter of Dhanasar

Part I: Decisions Issued August 3–17, 2026

This roundup reviews the 13 decisions issued from August 3 through August 17 in the August 2026 review. Each decision applies the three-part framework in Matter of Dhanasar: the proposed endeavor must have substantial merit and national importance; the petitioner must be well positioned to advance it; and, on balance, waiving the job-offer and labor-certification requirements must benefit the United States. The underlying EB-2 classification is a separate threshold requirement. INA § 203(b)(2); 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(k); Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016).

Published on:

On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) published a proposed rule that would rewrite the permanent labor certification program, known as PERM. The rule, titled “Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program,” appears at 91 Fed. Reg. 73916 (DOL Docket No. ETA-2026-0133). DOL has not revised the PERM regulations at 20 C.F.R. Part 656 in any comprehensive way since the 2004 rule that created the PERM system and the 2007 rule that targeted fraud. This proposal would change almost every stage of the process, from the first job advertisement through the approval of the employer’s immigrant petition.

This post opens a series on the proposed rule. Each later post takes one part of the proposal and explains what it would require, how it differs from current law, and what employers and foreign workers should do now.

What PERM is and why it matters

Published on:

The Board of Immigration Appeals recently ruled that an immigrant could not be released on bond because the record showed repeated motor vehicle violations, no clearly established U.S. address, and no demonstrated eligibility for relief from removal.

In Matter of Cruz Aijiaco, 30 I&N Dec. 218 (BIA 2026), decided November 2, 2026, the Board sustained the Department of Homeland Security’s appeal and ordered the respondent detained without bond. The decision appears among the latest BIA decisions posted by the Department of Justice.

The facts before the Board

Published on:

Introduction

We are discussing eight NIW decisions addressing proposed work in orthopedic surgery, semiconductor research, supply-chain consulting, cardiovascular research, financial risk, sustainable architecture, hearing research, and cybersecurity. Seven are appeals from USCIS denials. One is a combined motion to reopen and reconsider a prior NIW appeal.

These decisions are nonprecedent but provide useful information about adjudicative trends. Their value lies in the AAO’s explanation of the evidentiary shortcomings it identified in these cases.

Published on:

In Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, the Board of Immigration Appeals held that filing a motion to reopen after a voluntary departure deadline has passed does not undo the consequences of failing to depart on time. The Board issued the decision on November 5, 2026.

What happened

The respondent applied for cancellation of removal for nonpermanent residents. The Immigration Judge denied his application, and the Board dismissed his appeal on April 4, 2025. The Board reinstated a 60-day voluntary departure period, which ended June 3, 2025.

Published on:

A recent Administrative Appeals Office decision offers a useful reminder for people pursuing an EB-2 National Interest Waiver. USCIS may consider many kinds of evidence, but it cannot turn helpful examples into mandatory requirements that do not appear in the governing legal standard.

In In re 43786082, the AAO reviewed the denial of an NIW petition filed by a petitioner developing an artificial intelligence platform for preventive health care. The petitioner described the project as a tool for early risk identification, chronic disease prevention, and patient-centered care. USCIS agreed that the proposed work had substantial merit but found the evidence insufficient to establish national importance, that the petitioner was well positioned to advance the project, or that waiving the job offer requirement would benefit the United States.

The AAO withdrew the denial and remanded the case for a new decision. It did not approve the NIW petition or decide that the petitioner ultimately qualifies. In re 43786082, 2026 WL 3333511 (DHS Aug. 17, 2026). The decision is a nonprecedent decision, so it does not bind USCIS in other cases. It still provides a practical example of how the AAO applies the controlling framework.

Published on:

The earlier articles in this OPT series explained what the Final Rule requires for post-completion OPT and STEM OPT. This final installment addresses the questions that the regulatory text cannot answer by itself –  whether USCIS can process the expected volume of extension applications, how the agency will coordinate Forms I-539 and I-765, whether premium processing will become available, what happens when one application encounters a delay, and which legal theories may shape future challenges.

DHS openly acknowledges that the Final Rule will produce a substantial increase in extension-of-stay applications. Over its ten-year analysis period, DHS estimates an annual average of approximately 393,500 extension requests from F nonimmigrants, in addition to 28,000 from J nonimmigrants and 6,000 from I nonimmigrants. These figures cover the Final Rule as a whole, rather than OPT alone, but they illustrate the volume that USCIS, schools, students, and employers must absorb.

DHS expects the largest increase in extension filings to emerge about four years after the September 15, 2026 effective date, when many students and exchange visitors reach the outer limit of their initial or transitional admission periods. DHS believes this interval will give the agency time to adjust staffing, systems, and workflows. At the same time, DHS concedes that existing extension backlogs exist and expressly states that it cannot guarantee USCIS processing times.

The Chicago immigration lawyers of Zneimer & Zneimer P.C. are studying the Final Rule and explaining its requirements throughout this series. This article distinguishes among what the rule requires, what DHS predicts in its preamble, and what remains uncertain as a matter of implementation or future litigation.

The Rule’s Implementation Calendar

The Final Rule does not move every F-1 student into the same procedural system on the same day. Its permanent rules and transition provisions operate on different timelines.

Event Date or period Practical significance
Publication of Final Rule July 17, 2026 Starts the 60-day implementation period
Stated effective date September 15, 2026 Fixed admission framework begins, subject to congressional review
Temporary Form I-539 exemption for qualifying OPT and STEM OPT filings Through March 18, 2027 Certain students covered by the transition rules need only file Form I-765
Possible extension of temporary exemption Six-month increments DHS may extend the exemption only by publishing a Federal Register notice
Expected major increase in EOS volume Approximately four years after the effective date DHS expects the largest workload increase around September 2030
Outer transition date for qualifying F nonimmigrants admitted for D/S November 14, 2030 Four years from the effective date plus the former 60-day F-1 departure period

The November 14, 2030 date does not apply to every F-1 student. It serves as the outside date for qualifying F nonimmigrants who properly maintained status on September 15, 2026 and entered under Duration of Status. Their actual transition date may occur earlier, depending upon the program end date on the Form I-20 or the expiration date on an existing EAD.

A qualifying transition student who timely files Form I-765 for post-completion OPT or STEM OPT by March 18, 2027 may avoid the new Form I-539 requirement for that requested training period. DHS may extend that deadline in six-month increments, but only through a Federal Register notice. Students and DSOs should not assume that DHS will grant an extension unless the agency actually publishes one.

DHS Has Promised Guidance, but the Operating Details Will Continue to Develop

DHS states that updates to the SEVIS, CBP, and USCIS systems are underway. It also promises detailed implementation guidance, stakeholder outreach, and training for DSOs and government officers. DHS identifies the Study in the States website, the SEVP Response Center, the USCIS Contact Center, and CBP resources as principal sources of implementation information.

That commitment matters because the regulatory text does not resolve every operational question. For example, USCIS currently anticipates using Form I-539 for F-1 extension requests, but DHS retained general regulatory language so that USCIS may adopt a different form if workload or efficiency considerations justify a change. USCIS may also require biometrics and an interview in individual cases.

Schools, students, and employers therefore must distinguish between three types of authority:

  1. The Final Rule, which establishes binding legal requirements.
  2. USCIS and SEVP instructions, which will explain how applicants must satisfy those requirements.
  3. Institutional procedures, which schools and employers must create to track filings, employment authorization, and immigration deadlines.

A school policy cannot replace a regulatory requirement. At the same time, the regulation alone may not tell a student which online filing path to use, how USCIS will link related cases, or how quickly SEVIS will reflect an approval. Those matters will depend on agency implementation.

The Expected Filing Volume Is Substantial Continue reading →

Published on:

The Department of Homeland Security’s Final Rule does not eliminate the 24-month STEM OPT extension. It also preserves the existing rule that automatically extends a qualifying student’s post-completion OPT Employment Authorization Document for up to 180 days while a timely STEM OPT application remains pending.

The Final Rule does, however, add a separate immigration requirement for most students who seek STEM OPT under the new fixed-admission system. After the temporary transition period ends, a student who remains inside the United States ordinarily must file:

  1. Form I-765 to request the 24-month STEM OPT employment authorization; and
Published on:

The Department of Homeland Security’s Final Rule , Establishing a Fixed Time Period of Admission and an Extension of Stay Procedure for Nonimmigrant Academic Students, Exchange Visitors, and Representatives of Foreign Information Media, 91 Fed. Reg. 44,976 (July 17, 2026), makes three major changes that directly affect post-completion Optional Practical Training. The Final Rule takes effect on September 15, 2026, subject to the congressional review process described in the rule

  1. First, an F-1 student will receive admission for the period necessary to complete the course of study shown on the Form I-20, subject to a maximum of four years. The four-year limit is a maximum, not an automatic four-year admission for every student.
  2. Second, except for students who qualify for temporary transition relief, an F-1 student seeking post-completion OPT must obtain both employment authorization and an additional period of F-1 admission. A student who remains in the United States generally must apply to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services for employment authorization and an extension of stay. Alternatively, the student may travel abroad and seek admission from U.S. Customs and Border Protection for the OPT period. Approval of the Form I-765 alone will not provide the complete immigration authorization required under the Final Rule.
Published on:

Optional Practical Training (OPT) is an important benefits available to F-1 students. Every year, tens of thousands of international students rely on OPT to obtain practical experience in their field of study, transition into the American workforce, and, for many, pursue H-1B status or employment-based permanent residence.

The Department of Homeland Security’s July 17, 2026 Final Rule, Establishing a Fixed Time Period of Admission and an Extension of Stay Procedure for Nonimmigrant Academic Students, Exchange Visitors, and Representatives of Foreign Information Media, 91 Fed. Reg. 44976 (July 17, 2026).,  does not eliminate OPT. Instead, it changes the immigration framework within which OPT operates. For more than forty years, most F-1 students remained in the United States under Duration of Status (D/S). Under the Final Rule, DHS replaces that system with fixed periods of admission and, in many cases, requires students to file applications to extend their stay with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).

For universities, Designated School Officials (DSOs), employers, immigration attorneys, and students, the key question is no longer simply “Is my OPT approved?” The new question is “Does my OPT fit within my authorized period of admission, or must I obtain an extension of stay?”

Contact Information